RT Journal Article
T1 Responding to stories
A1 Robert Bud
YR 2014
VO 1
IS Spring 2014
K1 discourse and museums
K1  Henry Roscoe
K1  Loan collection
K1  Lyon Playfair
K1  Norman Lockyer
K1  Patent Office Museum
K1  Richard Glazebrook
K1  Royal Commission on Museums and Galleries
K1  Royal Commission on Scientific Instruction
K1  scientific apparatus
K1  scientific instrument exhibition
K1  Science Museum
K1  Society for Scientific Industry
K1  South Kensington Museum
AB This article argues that it is useful to see historical exhibitions as both responses and contributors to narratives about science that are circulating in the public sphere. It uses the example of the 1876 Loan Collection of Scientific Apparatus (which was the immediate predecessor of the Science Museum in London). The article demonstrates how, in promoting this huge exhibition and fighting for the necessary support and resources, leading scientific, cultural and political figures engaged with two rather different public interpretations of science’s past, present and future. One dealt with science as a vigorous part of culture with a fascinating and under-appreciated past and a dynamic future coming, internationally, to the fore. The other concerned the threat to Britain’s international economic ascendancy by countries with equal ingenuity and better education that could lead Britain into a decline reminiscent of the decline and fall of the Roman Empire. According to this second narrative, science would be the vaccine that would prevent this disease afflicting Britain. In the aftermath of the exhibition, the narratives were drawn upon again to form and sustain a permanent display that was known from 1885 as the Science Museum. While the memory of the Loan Collection itself was obscured in the 1920s during the Museum’s early life as a separate administrative body fighting for resources, the author suggests that continuity can be shown in the narrative arguments used by the creators of the two projects. A greater significance should therefore be given to this exhibition in the story of the development of the Science Museum.
PB The Science Museum Group
SN 2054-5770
LA eng
DO 10.15180/140104
UL http://journal.sciencemuseum.org.uk/browse/2014/responding-to-stories/
CR Armstrong, L, 1888, 'The Vague Cry for Technical Education', Nineteenth Century, July, pp 45–52
CR Arnold, M, 1874, Higher Schools and Universities in Germany (London: Macmillan)
CR Bell, D, 2009, The Idea of Greater Britain: Empire and the Future of World Order, 1860-1900 (Princeton: Princeton University Press)
CR Barton, R, 1990, '“An Influential Set of Chaps”: The X-Club and Royal Society Politics 1864-85', The British Journal for the History of Science, pp 23, 53–81
CR Barton, R, 2004, 'Scientific Authority and Scientific Controversy in Nature: North Britain against the X Club', in: Henson, L. (ed), Culture and Science in the Nineteenth-century Media (Ashgate Publishing), pp 223–35
CR Bud, R, 1995 'Science, Meaning and Myth in the Museum', Public Understanding of Science, 4: pp 1–16
CR Bud, R, 2009, 'Infected by the Bacillus of Science: The Explosion of South Kensington', Morris, Peter J T (ed), Science for the Nation: Perspectives on the History of the Science Museum (London: Palgrave Macmillan)
CR Bud, R, 2013, 'Framed in the public sphere: tools for the conceptual history of “applied science” – a review paper', History of Science, pp 51; 413–30
CR Bud, R, and Roberts, G K, 1984, Science versus Practice. Chemistry in Victorian Britain (Manchester University Press: Manchester)
CR Cardwell, D S L, 1957, The Organisation of Science in England – a Retrospect (London: William Heinemann)
CR Cho, S K, 2001, 'The Special Loan Collection of Scientific Apparatus, 1876: The Beginning of the Science Museum of London and the Popularization of Physical Science', PhD, (Seoul: Seoul National University)
CR Clercq, P de, 2002AA , 'The Special Loan Collection of Scientific Apparatus, South Kensington, 1876 Part 1 The Historical Treasures in the Illustrated London News', Bulletin of the Scientific Instrument Society, (72) (March): pp 14–19
CR Clercq, P de, 2002, 'The Special Loan Collection of Scientific Apparatus, South Kensington, 1876 Part 2 The Historical Instruments', Bulletin of the Scientific Instrument Society, (73) (June): pp 8–16
CR Clercq, P de, 2003, 'The Special Loan Collection of Scientific Apparatus, South Kensington, 1876 Part 4 Photographs and Copies. Bulletin of the Scientific Instrument Society, (76) (March): pp 10–15
CR Committee appointed by the Treasury to enquire into the science collections at South Kensington, Science collections at South Kensington. Report…with appendix, index, and minutes of evidence. PP. 1889 [C.5831]
CR Cooper, A E, 1909, 'Historical Memorandum by Mr Cooper on the Science Museum', Science Museum Series No. 1, ED 24/292, National Archives
CR Cooper, A, 1992, 'For the public good: Henry Cole, his circle and the development of the South Kensington estate', PhD (Open University)
CR Fontanon, C, 1990, 'Un Ingénieur Militaire Au Service de L’industrialisation: Arthur-Jules Morin (1795-1880)', Cahiers D’histoire et de Philosophie Des Sciences (29), pp 89–118
CR FRS, 1877, ‘A Science Museum’, The Times, 6 January
CR Gooday, G, 2000, 'Lies, Damned Lies and Declinism: Lyon Playfair, the Paris 1867 Exhibition and the Contested Rhetorics of Scientific Education and Industrial Performance', Inkster, I. (ed), The Golden Age: Essays in British Social and Economic History 1850–1870, (Ashgate, Aldershot, Hampshire), pp 105–20
CR Gooday, G, 2012, 'Vague and Artificial: The Historically Elusive Distinction between Pure and Applied Science', Isis 103, pp 546–54
CR Hooker, J D, 1876, draft of the President’s Address in JDH/4/10/2, Royal Botanic Gardens Kew
CR Hooker, J D, 1876a, President’s Address, Proceedings of the Royal Society, pp 339–56
CR Jacomy, B, 1995, 'Du Cabinet au Conservatoire', Journal of the History of Collections 7 (2) (January 1), pp 227–33
CR Kirchner, W, 1876, 'Ueber die Ausstellung der Wissenschaftlicher Apparate in London', offprint in the Science Museum Library, Special Collections
CR MacLeod, C, 2007, Heroes of Invention: Technology, Liberalism and British Identity, 1750-1914 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press)
CR Meadows, A J, 2011, Science and Controversy: a Biography of Sir Norman Lockyer. 2nd edition (London: Macmillan)
CR 'Museum of Science', 1876, Journal of the Society of Arts, 7 July, p 818
CR Playfair, Baron L P, 1888, 'Lord Armstrong and technical education', Nineteenth Century 24, pp 325–33
CR Roscoe, H, 1906, The life and experiences of Henry Enfield Roscoe D.C.L., LL.D., F.R.S. written by himself (London: Macmillan)
CR Royal Commission on National Museums and Galleries, 1928, Interim report 1928–29 [Cmd. 3192]
CR Royal Commission on National Museums and Galleries, 1930, Final report, part II. Conclusions and recommendations relating to individual institutions 1929–30 [Cmd. 3463]
CR Royal Commission on Scientific Instruction and the Advancement of Science, 1874, Fourth report [C.884]
CR Science and Art Department, 1858, Fifth report of the Science and Art Department 1857-58 PP [2385]
CR Science and Art Department, 1883, Thirtieth report of the Science and Art Department PP [C.3618]
CR Science and Art Department, 1885, Thirty-second report of the Science and Art Department, 1884–85 PP [C.4352]
CR Scott, G, 1876, '1851 Commissioners to The Secretary of the Treasury 21 June 1876, A Museum of Scientific Instruments and Objects', ED79/23, Z Archive, Science Museum London
CR Select Committee on the South Kensington Museum, 1860, Report of the committee, minutes of evidence, and appendix, together with the proceedings (504) (504–1)
CR Siemens, W, 1877, 'Remarks on the House of Applied Science, presented at the Iron and Steel Institute', reprinted in Bamber, E F, (ed), The Scientific Works of C. William Siemens (London: 1889), pp 154–55
CR 'South Kensington Museum', 1859, The Times, 19 December
CR South Kensington Museum 1874–1876, Board Minutes of the South Kensington Museum 1874–1876, ED 28/30 National Archives
CR 'The Press on the Loan Collection', 1876, Nature 14: 18 May, pp 14–43
WT Science Museum Group Journal
OL 30