RT Journal Article
T1 Flying Scotsman
A1 Andrew McLean
YR 2016
VO 5
IS Spring 2016
K1 Flying Scotsman
K1  Sir Nigel Gresley
K1  Alan Pegler
K1  London & North Eastern Railway
K1  British Railways
K1  National Railway Museum
AB Flying Scotsman is arguably the world’s most famous steam locomotive. The engine, a standard bearer of British engineering excellence and modernity in the 1920s, became, in the 1960s, a symbol of the dying age of steam. As Britain’s post war austerity and increasingly lesser role in the world gave way to Harold Wilson’s modernising ‘white heat of technology’ Britain’s ‘cult of the past’ took greater hold. Wistful nostalgia for the past can be seen across the cultural landscape of the 1960s in books, poetry, music, television and film. With a marked increase in the rise and popularity of preservation groups across the country this was a decade when interest in Britain’s ‘national heritage’ enjoyed enormous growth. Viewed within this context the remarkable saving of a steam locomotive from the scrapyard as Britain’s railway abandoned nineteenth century technology illustrates how the past has increasingly shaped Britain’s cultural landscape. This raises wider questions about what it means to preserve cultural objects and how, if at all, their authenticity can be preserved.

NO See, for example, Awdry, W, 1958, Duck and the Diesel Engine (London: Edmund Ward)
NO The phrase ‘the World’s most famous steam locomotive’ has been used since at least the 1960s (see reference to John Noakes in the text). A 2015 YouGov Global poll saw Flying Scotsman named as the most famous train or locomotive in the world. See, for example, ‘Flying Scotsman steams to head of world's most famous trains list’, Daily Telegraph, 30 November 2015
NO BBC Blue Peter first broadcast 13 October 1966: www.bbc.co.uk/archive/steamtrains/7320.shtml (accessed 3 January 2016)
NO Later the steam locomotive named Blue Peter would be rescued from being scrapped, in large part due to interest and support generated by viewers of the programme.
NO The Macniven and Cameron Flying Scotchman pen was extensively advertised in the 1880s and 1890s in national newspapers and magazines, e.g. Illustrated London News, 5 April 1884
NO The first trip was a jolly excursion in 1864 and the second, shortly after he had almost been killed in a rail accident in Kent, a more traumatic affair, exacerbated by the speed of the service. (Dickens’s fears were not overplayed: in 1876 the ‘Flying Scotchman’ crashed at Abbots Ripton in Huntingdonshire killing thirteen people.)
NO The LNER produced a publicity poster and book, 1925, The Flying Scotsman: The World’s Most Famous Train, 1st edition (London: LNER). The book was updated at regular intervals into the 1930s.
NO Gill not only designed the Flying Scotsman’s headboard but he hand-painted the original too, which he hand-fixed to the hauling locomotive 4475 Flying Fox. As part of his fee Gill would later be given a footplate ride on the train.
NO The train still runs today. At the time of writing this is currently a one-way service only from Edinburgh to London, leaving at 5.40am – the fastest run between the two cities in the timetable. It is operated by Virgin Trains East Coast.
NO BBC Desert Island Discs first broadcast 13 January 1969: www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p009y1d0 (accessed 4 January 2016)
NO See Rolt, L T C, 2001, The landscape trilogy: the autobiography of L.T.C. Rolt (Stroud: Sutton)
NO Strong made this comments after the hugely successful and heritage changing V&A show ‘Destruction of the Country House’ in 1974. Quoted in Sandbrook, D, 2010, State of Emergency: The way we were: Britain 1970–1974 (London: Allen Lane), pp 196–197
NO The phrase being used, for example, in ‘The Protection of Ancient Buildings’, The Times, 7 June 1883, p 6
NO This was an 1897 carriage of the Lynton & Barnstaple Railway NRM 1988-7002
NO For example, the Caledonian Railway ’Single’ locomotive number 123 was restored to her appearance from the time when she starred in the famous 1895 ‘Races to the North’, thus removing her later history in the service of the London Midland Scottish Railway and latterly British Railways.
NO Awdry, Enterprising Engines, p 10
NO The present writer recalls receiving just such a model for Christmas in 1978. My own recollection was one of confusion when comparing my model to historic photographs of the locomotive from the 1920s and 1930s.
NO The question of Flying Scotsman’sappearance – especially livery and number – is one of the most frequent issues raised by members of the public with the National Railway Museum today.
NO Subsequently, the myths surrounding this trade mission grew to suggest it had been financially supported by Wilson’s Government (for example, Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LNER_Class_A3_4472_Flying_Scotsman accessed on 26 February 2016) and only failed when the new Conservative Government under Edward Heath withdrew support. Other than a short letter of support from Wilson there is no evidence to support the belief that the mission had full government backing, the mission being entirely a private venture – see, for example, Pegler’s bankruptcy papers held in the National Archives (TNA B9/1647), which clearly show that the mission was funded by Pegler and other private individuals.
NO Flying Scotsman was rescued for a second time by a wealthy businessman, this time Sir William McAlpine who acquired her in 1973 and transported her back to Britain.
NO ‘Official Receiver’s Report to Court on the bankrupt’s application for discharge’ heard on 6 December 1974 in Pegler’s bankruptcy papers (TNA B9/1647/1).
NO Letter of 15 March 2005 held in NRM Technical File NRM/2004-7103/004
PB The Science Museum Group
SN 2054-5770
LA eng
DO 10.15180/160507
UL http://journal.sciencemuseum.org.uk/browse/issue-05/flying-scotsman/
CR Allen, Cecil J, 1946, Titled Trains of Great Britain, 1st edition (London: Ian Allan), p 10
CR Atkinson, F, 1999, The Man Who Made Beamish: An Autobiography (Gateshead: Northern Books), p 10
CR Awdry, Rev W, 1968, Enterprising Engines (London: Edmund Ward), p 6
CR Baily, M, 1968, ‘Cash for turbine train’, The Times, 1 November 1968, p 3
CR Baily, M, ‘Railways of Tomorrow, The Times, 9 July 1969, p 28
CR Baily, M, 1969, ‘Railways of Tomorrow: a special report on the railway technical centre at Derby. The second revolution’ in The Times, 9 July, p 28;
CR Bailey, T, 1970, ‘Kings Cross – Edinburgh Non-Stop’ in Pegler et al, Flying Scotsman, p 39
CR BBC Desert Island Discs, 13 January 1969
CR BBC documentary 4472-Flying Scotsman, first broadcast 11 August 1968: bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/p011vfqw/4472-flying-scotsman (accessed 3 June 2015)
CR Biddle, G, 1997, ‘Association of Railway Preservation Societies’ in Simmons, J and Biddle, G (eds), The Oxford Companion to British Railway History (Oxford: Oxford University Press), p 25
CR Brown, J, 2009, ‘Frank Atkinson and the Founding of Beamish’ in Journal of Museum Ethnography, December, p 122
CR Cannadine, D, 2002, In Churchill’s Shadow: Confronting the Past in Modern Britain (Oxford: Oxford University Press), pp 224–243
CR Coulls, A, 2015, ‘How much of Flying Scotsman is original?’: blog.nrm.org.uk/how-much-of-flying-scotsman-is-original (accessed 4 February 2016)
CR Daily Express, 28 December 1964
CR Dolby, G, 1912, Charles Dickens as I knew Him (New York: Charles Scribners), pp 33, 353
CR Edmonson, H, 1970, ‘Flying Scotsman in America’ in Pegler et al, Flying Scotsman,p 66; ‘Aid to exports…or just a poor show’, The Times, 18 November 1969, p 25
CR Filmer-Sankey, W, 1998, ‘History of the Victorian Society’ in The Victorian, the magazine of the Victorian Society, reproduced on: http://www.victorian-society.org.uk/history-of-the-victorian-society/ (accessed 7 January 2016)
CR Gourvish, T, 1986, British Railways, 1948–73 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press), p 460
CR Gwynne, B, 2011, Railway Preservation in Britain (Oxford: Shire), pp 30–31
CR Howard, P, ‘No regrets by the man who travelled from wealth to penury on the Flying Scotsman’, The Times, 7 December 1974, p 3
CR Kitton, F G, 1892, ‘A Night Ride on the Flying Scotchman’, The Strand Magazine, vol.III, number 14, February, pp 195–201
CR Kynaston, D, 2015, Modernity Britain 1957–1962 London: Bloomsbury), pp 502–503
CR McLean, A, 2015, ‘The many guises of Flying Scotsman’, NRM blog, 11 March 2015: blog.nrm.org.uk/many-guises-of-flying-scotsman (accessed 4 February 2016)
CR McLean, A, 2016, The Flying Scotsman: Speed, Style, Service (London: Scala), pp 14, 140, 146–147
CR ‘The First Hundred Years’ in Newby, H (ed), 1995, The National Trust: The Next Hundred Years (London: National Trust), pp 22, 26
CR Letter printed in The Oxford Times, 30 July 1864, p 8
CR Alan Pegler, ‘Living with No 4472’ in Pegler, A, Allen, C J, Bailey, T and Edmonson, H, 1970, Flying Scotsman, 2nd enlarged edition (London: Ian Allan), p 32
CR Railway Magazine, March 1963, p 187
CR Railway Magazine, March 1963, p 187
CR Railway Magazine, February 1968, p v
CR Railway Magazine, March 1968, p 129
CR Raynor, H, 1968, ‘Enthusiasm for steam’, The Times, 12 August, p 5
CR Sandbrook, D, 2006, Never Had It So Good: A History of Britain from Suez to the Beatles (London: Abacus), p 122
CR Sandbrook, D, 2010, State of Emergency: The way we were: Britain 1970–1974 (London: Allen Lane), pp 195–199
CR Simmons, J, 1981, Dandy Cart to Diesel: The National Railway Museum (London: HMSO), p 51
CR Stamp, G, 2007, Britain’s Lost Cities (London: Aurum), p 115
CR Stamp, G, 2010, Lost Victorian Britain. How the Twentieth Century Destroyed the Nineteenth Century’s Architectural Masterpieces (London: Aurum), pp 39–57
CR ‘Businessman Buys Flying Scot’, The Times, 9 January 1963, p 4
CR ‘Transport Museums’, The Times, 18 August 1964, p 9
CR ‘Dr Beeching to Hand Over Transport’, The Times, 24 December 1964, p 8
CR ‘Thirsty “Scot” stops to drink’, The Times, 2 May 1968, p 4
CR ‘Train trip marks the end of steam’, The Times, 12 August 1968, p 2
CR The Times, 18 Nov 1969
CR Wickens, A, 2008, ‘The APT with hindsight’ at http://www.apt-p.com/APTWithHindsight.htm (accessed 20 February 2016)
CR Williams, H, 1985, APT – A Promise Unfulfilled (London, Ian Allan), p 111
WT Science Museum Group Journal
OL 30